I just saw SiCKO and was quite impressed by it. Moore has been criticized for his stunts in the film, especially the Cuba trip, and for painting an overly-rosy view of other countries, but I don’t think he’s really off the mark. Having lived now in four countries with universal health care (UK, France, Belgium and the Netherlands, for those keeping track), I do agree that universal health care systems are better than the American system. Why I don’t have much experience with these other countries (having been pretty healthy), I can saw that my experiences with the French and British systems were very good. It was very cool being given an NHS number when I was living the London just because I was living there legally for over six months. No fuss, no muss.
Ironically, one of the difficulties our family had in moving to France was showing we had health insurance in order to get our visas. We were required to show health insurance covering our entire stay. Like most Americans, our health insurance was from my father’s employer. Thus, the insurer was unwilling to certify that the insurance was valid for our entire stay. In the end my father’s boss had to write a letter promising that my father would be employed for the entire period and thus ensuring health insurance!
To be honest, what disappointed me about the film was the befuddled everyman perspective Moore takes: “But I thought Americans took care of each other.” I kept wanting to yell, “Of course we don’t! We’re heartless assholes that would rather destroy ourselves than do anything remotely socialistic!” I’ll give him that appealing to people’s better instincts is probably more effective in changing things than berating them for their narrow-minded and selfish attitudes. Being one more prone to calm dialog than arguments and accusations (which is why I don’t support Greenpeace, but that’s another story…), it perhaps ironic for me to say it, but in this case I subscribe to the Henry Rollins school of rage for civic good (watch the entire video, it’s very moving). Sure Moore takes some pot-shots at HMOs, but he really doesn’t indite American society the way I would have liked. In that sense I would consider Bowling for Columbine a more critical film.